Lydia Berman chose her son’s nursery because it was close to home, family-run and affordable.
But suddenly, the fees went up and she was being asked to pay extra for nappies and wipes.
Berman is among a growing number of parents who have seen their nurseries bought out by private equity-backed chains, which have come under fire for allegedly using parent’s fees to give millions to shareholders instead of investing in the quality of childcare provided.
Shorts
Southport killer charged on suspicion of attacking prison staff
Southport killer Axel Rudakubana, 19, has been charged with multiple assaults on prison staff at HMP Belmarsh.
Rudakubana, 18, was sentenced to a minimum of 52 years in January this year for the murders of the three girls (Elizabeth Cook/PA)
The charges in full
Rudakubana has been charged with two counts of assaulting an emergency worker, one of attempted grievous bodily harm and another for unauthorised possession of an offensive weapon in prison.
The alleged offences took place over three separate attacks between 6 May and 28 October last year.
He was charged on Tuesday, 28 July, and will appear at Magistrates’ Court via videolink on Friday, 11 September.
In May last year, it was alleged that Rudakubana used a kettle to heat water and then poured it over a prison officer.
52-year minimum sentence
Rudakubana is serving a life sentence with a minimum of 52 years for the murders of Alice da Silva Aguiar, Bebe King and Elsie Dot Stancombe, and the attempted murder of eight other children and two adults at a Taylor Swift-themed class in Southport in July 2024.
Caption: Court artist sketch by Elizabeth Cook of Southport stabbings suspect Axel Rudakubana, 18, shouting from the dock as he appeared at Liverpool Crown Court, for his sentencing hearing after he pleaded guilty to murdering three young girls in a knife attack at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class. Southport killer Axel Rudakubana repeatedly interrupted his sentencing hearing by shouting for a paramedic and claiming to be ill, having not eaten for 10 days. Picture date: Thursday January 23, 2025. PA Photo. Rudakubana has also pleaded guilty to the attempted murder of eight other children and to the attempted murder of Leanne Lucas and Jonathan Hayes in Southport, Merseyside on July 29, 2024.See PA story COURTS Southport . Photo credit should read: Elizabeth Cook/PA Wire
Photographer: Elizabeth Cook Provider: Elizabeth Cook/PA Wire Source: PA Copyright: PA
Caption: SOUTHPORT, ENGLAND – JULY 29: People begin to lay flowers outside the The Atkinson for the first anniversary of the Southport stabbings that left three girls dead on July 29, 2025 in Southport, England. 17-year-old Axel Rudakubana, armed with a knife, attacked children at a Taylor Swift-themed holiday club in Hart Lane, Southport, a year ago today. Elsie Dot Stancombe, 7, Bebe King, 6, and Alice da Silva Aguiar, 9, died, and nine children and two adults were treated in hospital for their wounds. Rudakubana was tried on 16 charges, including murder and attempted murder and sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 52 years. (Photo by Christopher Furlong/Getty Images) Photographer: Christopher Furlong Provider: Getty Images Source: Getty Images Europe
Last week, it emerged that Rudakubana had been moved from prison to Broadmoor, the high-security psychiatric hospital in Berkshire, following a clinical assessment.
news
Fifa vows to press ahead with controversial World Cup plan – the latest
Donald Trump with Fifa president Gianni Infantino at the World Cup after presenting the trophy to winners Spain (Photo: Alex Pantling/Getty)
Fifa has said it will push ahead with its decision to sell stakes in the World Cup to private investors following backlash.
The governing body insisted that “nobody is selling football” but European nations agreed to boycott Fifa competitions.
UEFA ‘unequivocally rejects’ FIFA plan
In an emergency meeting on Thursday, Uefa’s 55 member countries resolved to “unequivocally reject” Fifa president Gianni Infantino’s plan to sell stakes in the World Cup less than 48 hours after The Times revealed it.
Caption: EAST RUTHERFORD, NEW JERSEY – JULY 19: Lionel Messi #10 of Argentina reacts after the 0-1 loss during the FIFA World Cup 2026 Final match between Spain and Argentina at New York New Jersey Stadium on July 19, 2026 in East Rutherford, New Jersey. (Photo by Hector Vivas – FIFA/FIFA via Getty Images) Photographer: Hector Vivas – FIFA Provider: FIFA via Getty Images Source: FIFA Copyright: 2026 FIFA Spurs defender Djed Spence had admirers at Everton (Photo: Getty)
Infantino’s proposal, called Fifa Forward Enterprise (FFE), was dealt another blow later when North America’s body, Concacaf, and the Asian Football Confederation joined Uefa in rejecting the plan. His advisor, Carlos Cordeiro, has also resigned.
FIFA blames ‘incorrect media reports’ for disrupting process
Despite the backlash, Fifa has not withdrawn the plan, and instead said it would continue with a consultation period on the decision.
In a statement released on Friday morning, Fifa said they “respect the feedback and concern aired” but blamed “incorrect media reports” for disrupting the process.
NEWS
2 min read
Explained
3 min read
Plan explores ‘commercial opportunity’ of football
FFE has been proposed solely to ensure that all Fifa Member Associations (MAs) have the opportunity to take meaningful ownership of the commercial opportunity of football in their respective countries, and that this does not come at the cost of either the spirit or the governance of Fifa or football itself.
UEFA said in a statement
Fifa president Gianni Infantino wants to sell stakes in the World Cup to private investors (Photo: Getty)
$20bn: The price of influence over future World Cups
The effort is being bankrolled by Joshua Kushner, the brother of Jared Kushner, Donald Trump’s son-in-law.
A deadline of 19 September has been set for associations to accept the plan, with a majority vote needed for it to go ahead.
Here’s what FIFA’s plans entail:
Infantino has opened a consultation for the sale of a stake in FFE that would raise $20bn (£15bn) in exchange for influence over future World Cups.
That includes broadcasting and commercial deals linked to the tournament.
The proposal would trigger over $80m (£60m) in payouts to each of Fifa’s 211 member associations between now and 2037.
Caption: Migrants try to cross from Morocco into the Spanish enclave of Ceuta, Thursday, July 30, 2026. (AP Photo/Antonio Sempere) Photographer: Antonio Sempere Provider: AP Photo/Antonio Sempere Source: AP
news
Thousands of migrants cross Spain-Morocco border
Thousands of migrants swam from Morocco to Spain’s North African enclave of Ceuta on Thursday, prompting a increase of security in the area.
At least 18 people drowned while attempting the crossing, which is about 3.1 miles long.
The latest
It was unclear how many people crossed the border, but Spain’s interior ministry estimates 49,000 crossed in the last 24 hours, official estimates state.
There were unconfirmed reports of clashes in Ceuta.
There were also of migrants crossing the border in Melilla.
Exclusive
3 min read
Spanish PM pledged to return things in Ceuta to normal
A Spanish official said the border was in total collapse, the BBC reported.
Spain’s Prime Minister, Pedro Sanchez, is due in the territory on Friday along with his interior minister, Fernando Grande-Marlaska.
Sanchez has so far resisted declaring a national emergency.
WORLD
4 min read
OPINION
3 min read
Migrants cannot be returned
Local officials appealed to Madrid for help after a recent rise in attempted crossings.
Spain’s Supreme Court ruled this month that migrants stopped at sea while trying to reach Ceuta or Melilla, another Spanish enclave, cannot be returned to Morocco.
Caption: Migrants cross from Morocco into the Spanish enclave of Ceuta, Thursday, July 30, 2026. (AP Photo/Antonio Sempere) Photographer: Antonio Sempere Provider: AP Photo/Antonio Sempere Source: AP
Explained
3 min read
Italy mulls closing border to Spain
Spain’s interior ministry accused human trafficking networks of exploiting the fresh Supreme Court ruling to “encourage the flow of undocumented migrants”.
Italy’s Prime Minister, Giorgia Meloni (Photo: Filippo MONTEFORTE / AFP via Getty Images)Caption: CEUTA, SPAIN – MAY 19: A young migrant who has crossed the border between Spain and Morocco by swimming along the Tarajal beach, steps out of the sea towards a member of the Civil Guard, before he is returned to Morocco on May 19, 2021 in Ceuta, Spain. After a diplomatic conflict between Spain and Morocco, thousands of migrants have taken advantage of the little Moroccan police activity to cross the border, mainly by swimming. This has caused a migration crisis, with the entry of more than 8000 migrants from the African country. (Photo by Joan Amengual/VIEWpress/Corbis via Getty Image ) Photographer: VIEW press Provider: Corbis via Getty Images Source: Corbis News Copyright: 2021@VIEWpress
The breach has prompted backlash from Italy’s government, which said it was considering closing the open border Schengen agreement with Spain. France has also announced it will strengthen border checks with Spain.
In pictures: Thousands cross the Spain-Morocco border
Caption: Migrants gather around a torched vehicle while waiting for a chance to cross to the Spanish enclave of Ceuta, on the Moroccan side of the border in Fnideq, Morocco, July 31, 2026. Picture taken with a mobile phone. REUTERS/Ahmed El Jechtimi TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY Photographer: Ahmed El Jechtimi Provider: REUTERS Source: REUTERS
Caption: CEUTA, SPAIN – JULY 30: Hundreds of migrants have attempted to swim from Morocco to the Spanish city of Ceuta in North Africa, while the number of arrivals exceeded 1,500 in just over a week, according to local news in Cueta, Spain on July 30, 2026. As Moroccan and Algerian migrants attempted to reach Ceuta by swimming, most were reportedly intercepted by Moroccan patrol boats. Spain’s Maritime Rescue Service and the Spanish Red Cross rescued 117 people from the water, while the Civil Guard assisted around 200 others with patrol boats. The Spanish Civil Guard also found two bodies which raised the death toll along Ceuta’s coastline so far this year to 29. (Photo by Marcos Moreno/Anadolu via Getty Images) Photographer: Anadolu Provider: Anadolu via Getty Images Source: Anadolu Caption: Migrants try to cross from Morocco into the Spanish enclave of Ceuta, Thursday, July 30, 2026. (AP Photo/Antonio Sempere) Photographer: Antonio Sempere Provider: AP Photo/Antonio Sempere Source: AP
Watch more on this topic
Migrants flood into Spain’s Ceuta exclave from Morocco.
Madrid says it will despatch soldiers to Ceuta to ensure security after thousands of migrants entered Spain’s north African exclave from neighbouring Morocco and hundreds more are headed there pic.twitter.com/A9oaQ4OCu7
Ex-Royal Marine featured in Netflix documentary missing after avalanche
A renowned climber who served in the British Special Forces is missing after an avalanche on one of the world’s highest mountains.
Nims Purja on the summit of Gasherbrum II (Photo: Nirmal Purja/PA Wire)
Broad Peak avalanche
Nirmal Purja scaled the world’s 14 highest peaks in record time in 2019, a feat documented on Netflix and in his bestselling memoir Beyond Possible.
Here’s what we know about the incident:
Purja was leading a team on the 8,051m Broad Peak in northern Pakistan.
An avalanche struck on Thursday between 8.57am and 9.30am local time, and communication with the group was lost.
Three GPS trackers have been located at altitudes ranging from roughly 6,000m to 7,000m, according to local officials.
The Alpine Club of Pakistan said four bodies had been found.
It identified two of them as Nadhira Al Harthy from Oman, and Pur Bahadur Gurung “Yukta” from Nepal.
‘Still some tiny hopes’
As well as those confirmed to have died, Purja was on the mountain with four other Nepalese climbers plus nationals from Pakistan, China and the US.
Himal Gautam, a spokesperson for Nepal’s Tourism Department said the incident was “unprecedented” but hope remains.
Caption: FILE PHOTO: Mountaineers practice walking on a ladder during a training session at Everest base camp, Nepal April 15, 2025. REUTERS/Purnima Shrestha/File Photo Photographer: Purnima Shrestha Provider: REUTERS Source: REUTERS
Big Read
10 min read
Who is Nirmal Purja?
Purja, 43, is one of the world’s most renowned climbers.
He scaled the world’s 14 highest peaks in a record six months in 2019 – Norwegian climber Kristin Harila beat him four years later. Purja, who was born in Nepal, was in the military for 16 as part of the Royal Marines and Special Forces.
Having spent a decade in the special forces, Nims Purja decided that he needed a new challenge (Photo: Netflix) Mountaineer Nirmal “Nims” Purja is the subject of Netflix documentary ’14 Peaks: Nothing is Impossible’
WORLD
All you need to know as Trump announces Hamas disarmament
Caption: A fireball erupts following an Israeli strike near a tent encampment sheltering people displaced by war in Deir el-Balah in the central Gaza Strip on March 25, 2026. Violence has persisted in Gaza despite a ceasefire which came into effect on October 10, with both Israel and Hamas regularly accusing each other of violations. (Photo by Eyad Baba / AFP via Getty Images) Photographer: EYAD BABA Provider: AFP via Getty Images Source: AFP Copyright: AFP or licensors
The Board of Peace has reached an agreement for the “complete disarmament” of Hamas and other armed groups in Gaza, Donald Trump has said.
In an announcement late on Thursday, Trump called it “a critical step towards Gaza finally being governed by a new Palestinian government”.
‘Intensive’ negotiations
Hamas has not made an official announcement but a senior figure told the BBC they had agreed to a complete phased disarmament in Gaza.
The Board of Peace – established by Trump in January – said the agreement concludes months of “intensive, good faith negotiations”, and is now focused on implementation.
More than 90 per cent of homes in Gaza were destroyed during the war (Photo: Omar Al-Qattaa/AFP/Getty Images) Hamas forces have regained control in half of Gaza (Photo : Doaa Albaz/Anadolu/ Getty)
Inside the US-brokered ceasefire plan
It is part of the US-brokered Gaza ceasefire plan announced last year, which includes the phased disarmament of Hamas, the gradual withdrawal of all Israeli troops, and the reconstruction of Gaza.
Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has dismissed a push from the mayor of New York City to arrest him (Photo: Nathan Howard/AFP)Caption: President Donald Trump speaks about Dulles International Airport modernization, in the Oval Office of the White House, Wednesday, July 29, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson) Photographer: Julia Demaree Nikhinson Provider: AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson Source: AP Copyright: Copyright 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.
The agreement, seen by the BBC, provides for the inventorying and storage of Hamas’s remaining heavy weapons under Palestinian supervision.
US ‘disappointed’ if Israel doesn’t withdraw
Israel has yet to comment on the plan.
US officials say that Trump will be “very disappointed” if Israel does not withdraw as part of the agreement.
The US believes Israel would continue to be a good partner.
It marks the first time that a Hamas figure has said they would completely disarm, though that is conditional on Israel’s withdrawal.
Analysis
4 min read
Nurseries owned by private equity firms spent at least £82m more than not-for-profits on costs such as directors’ pay, rents and loans in 2023/24, according to analysis shared with The i Paper.
These excess costs include repayments and interest charges for debts taken on by nursery firms to pay for takeovers of more settings, according to Trinava Consulting, which examined the companies’ annual accounts. It said rents are often inflated to extract returns for investors.
The nine biggest private equity-owned chains in the UK spent 15 per cent more of their income on these non-frontline costs than large not-for-profit providers, and nine per cent less on staffing, the firm’s analysis found.
The two private equity-owned nursery chains with the highest number of places, Kids Planet and Bright Stars, gave pay packets worth £335,000 and £266,000 respectively to senior directors.
But the highest-paid director, earning £400,000 last year, was at Grandir UK – which has more than 95 locations across the UK, according to The i Paper‘s analysis of the most recent Companies House data.
Parents and staff who have worked for nurseries bought by private equity firms told The i Paper the takeovers resulted in fee increases, additional charges, lower-quality food and toys for children, and losses of highly-qualified staff members.
The UK competition watchdog is investigating the role private equity and other ownership models are playing in the childcare market, including whether they are working in the interests of families or driving up costs.
It comes as the number of childcare places offered by private equity-backed nurseries has doubled, while the number of places available at not-for-profit providers and childminders has fallen by eight per cent and nearly 40 per cent respectively, according to research from University College London and the Government.
The Competition and Markets Authority is also looking at reports that parents are being charged compulsory add-ons or additional hours to access their entitlements. Working parents of children aged nine months to four years can access 30 hours of Government-funded childcare but often pay for additional hours.
Louise O’Hare, of the Post Pandemic Childcare coalition and Public Childcare Now campaign, said private firms “charge high prices to parents, whilst staff qualifications are amongst the lowest” and many are paid below the living wage.
She said the private childcare sector has “badly and evidently failed” and urged the Government to “properly value early years staff and end privatisation – establishing a national pay scale, ending funding to nurseries that give profits to shareholders, and shifting to universal, directly- funded, and democratically accountable local provision”.
How private equity firms work
Private equity firms pool money from investors and use it, frequently in combination with debt, to buy companies.
They aim to increase the value of the company they bought, by, for example, streamlining operations, cutting costs or expanding into new markets.
They then sell the company. The profits go back to investors, while the firm keeps a portion as their fee. The business model is often compared to “house flipping” in real estate.
Private equity firms argue that they hold investments for an average of six years – longer than many equities held by large shareholders and hedge funds – and support the growth of businesses. However, their primary focus is to buy companies and resell them for a profit.
Parents ‘overcharged for extras’
Berman, a 48-year marketing agency owner, was paying around £60 a day when her son first started attending Moor End Farm Day Nursery in Boxmoor, Hemel Hempstead, in 2021.
The couple who owned it had constructed a purpose-built nursery on their farmland, surrounded by animals.
In 2023, the nursery was bought by Kindred Nurseries, a chain owned by private equity firm Livingbridge.
Lydia Berman chose her nursery because it was independent and family-run (Photo: Supplied)
Berman said fees had risen to more than £80 a day by 2025, when her son last attended the nursery.
Under Kindred, the nursery changed its fee for consumables from a daily charge to a flat monthly fee that was the same regardless of how many days parents used the nursery each week.
Berman said some parents complained about this and about being charged for nappies when their children no longer required them.
“They had these rules that did not make sense,” she said.
Kindred’s monthly consumables fees for children over three in 2025 were £60 a month for food, £7.50 for things other than food, and £32.50 for activities, according to its website.
Sarah Ronan, executive director of the Early Education and Childcare Coalition, said many small, independent providers are “struggling to keep their doors open” because Government funding does not fully cover the cost of delivering “free” hours for parents.
“Childcare needs greater investment, but it matters what kind of investment that is and where the money ultimately goes,” she said.
“Public funding should support decent wages for early years professionals, high-quality inclusive provision for children and more places in underserved communities, rather than servicing unnecessarily complex financial arrangements and extracting value from an already fragile system.”
Vivek Kotecha, director of Trinava Consulting, said that if the growth of “extractive investment” in nurseries is left to continue, “large financialised nursery chains will start to dominate: squeezing both staff and parents”.
‘Parents are trapped’
Maria, who spoke using a pseudonym, saw her childcare fees go up after the nursery her daughters attended was acquired by private equity-owned Bright Stars in 2018.
Bright Stars, formerly named ICP Education, was founded by Innervation Capital Partners and sold to Oakley Capital in 2021 – both private equity firms.
Maria’s nursery, Montessori on the Park in Tower Hamlets, London, put up fees by around five per cent in 2019, 10 per cent in 2023 and eight per cent in 2024, documents seen by The i Paper show.
“Effectively, your child was already settled in a nursery space, seemed happy enough, and there wasn’t any other childcare available, so you’re pretty much trapped in that scenario when people just add extra charges,” said Maria, a 44-year-old policy researcher.
Consumable fees also rose, reaching £78 a month for children who attended three full days a week in 2024, including the 30 Government-funded hours.
That year, she moved her youngest daughter to a cheaper, not-for-profit provider at a school in her area.
“The experience at the school-based nursery was quantifiably different, with staff consistent and a very clear leadership structure,” she said. “My child is in reception and the same nursery staff are there still, and she sees them at after-school club.
“This experience is of a community school, with council pay scales, running a nursery itself – not outsourcing it to a private company.”
Frozen food replaced organic, fresh food
A former worker at the Montessori on the Park nursery in Tower Hamlets said some staff who had worked there for years left after it was sold off. Staff holiday allocations were reduced by several weeks by the new owners.
She said the food budget was cut from around £1,000 a week to £350 a week for the same number of children, but fees were not reduced for parents to reflect that.
“I remember actually crying, thinking this is a bad dream,” she said.
She claimed that children went from eating organic, fresh food, including meat, to frozen food from a wholesale supplier because of the budget cuts.
She said the nursery would not take children who could only do the 30 Government-funded hours and would instead accept parents who paid for additional hours on top of this.
Extra training offered to staff often came with stipulations about how much longer they had to work for the nursery, which dissuaded them from completing it.
Children left with broken toys and ripped books
A former staff member at another nursery bought by Bright Stars – Springburn Childcare in Hungerford, Berkshire – said they struggled with budget cuts after the takeover.
They claimed the nursery was left with just £250 a month to spend on supplies for its 84 children after food and essentials were factored in.
The staff member said books would get ripped or chewed up and had to be taped together as a “temporary fix” because they could not be replaced.
“It was the same for wooden toys that had broken – for example, a wooden stacking train or something where one of the wheels had come off,” they said. “The children would just have to play with it as is.”
Children would also get bored due to the lack of variety in toys, they added.
At Thrive Gilsland Manor House in Edinburgh, which is owned by private equity firm Apiary Capital, managers would prioritise accepting parents who wanted their children in the nursery five days a week and paid for extra hours on top of the Government-funded provision, according to a former staff member.
She was earning about £13 per hour – close to the living wage. Forty-five minutes of paid breaks were cut in recent years, leaving staff with just 30 minutes for a lunch break in a 10-hour shift.
Around a year and a half ago, when she left, the nursery was charging about £80 a day.
The not-for-profit she now works at in Edinburgh charges £65 a day.
The owners of Bright Stars, Partou and Kids Planet declined to comment. The owners of the other nurseries named in this article did not respond to a request for comment.
Do you have information that could help us investigate this? We’d love to hear from you. Please email alexa.phillips@theipaper.com
Leave a comment